Early contact between late farming and pastoralist societies in southeastern Europe
Penske S, Rohrlach AB, Childebayeva A et al.
Publication Details
Comprehensive information about this research publication
Abstract
Summary of the research findings
Archaeogenetic studies have described two main genetic turnover events in prehistoric western Eurasia: one associated with the spread of farming and a sedentary lifestyle starting around 7000-6000 BC (refs. 1-3) and a second with the expansion of pastoralist groups from the Eurasian steppes starting around 3300 BC (refs. 4,5). The period between these events saw new economies emerging on the basis of key innovations, including metallurgy, wheel and wagon and horse domestication6-9. However, what happened between the demise of the Copper Age settlements around 4250 BC and the expansion of pastoralists remains poorly understood. To address this question, we analysed genome-wide data from 135 ancient individuals from the contact zone between southeastern Europe and the northwestern Black Sea region spanning this critical time period. While we observe genetic continuity between Neolithic and Copper Age groups from major sites in the same region, from around 4500 BC on, groups from the northwestern Black Sea region carried varying amounts of mixed ancestries derived from Copper Age groups and those from the forest/steppe zones, indicating genetic and cultural contact over a period of around 1,000 years earlier than anticipated. We propose that the transfer of critical innovations between farmers and transitional foragers/herders from different ecogeographic zones during this early contact was integral to the formation, rise and expansion of pastoralist groups around 3300 BC.
Ancient DNA Samples
133 ancient DNA samples referenced in this publication
| Sample ID | Date/Era | Country | Locality | Sex | mtDNA | Y-DNA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTK001 | 4656 BCE | Bulgaria | Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) | M | HV+16311 |
M436/P214/PF3856/S33 |
| PTK003 | 4674 BCE | Bulgaria | Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) | M | H3aq |
V88 |
| PTK004 | 4656 BCE | Bulgaria | Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) | M | H3aq |
M436/P214/PF3856/S33 |
| PTK005 | 4700 BCE | Bulgaria | Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) | M | U2+152 |
CTS5990/Z1903 |
| BOY008 | 2899 BCE | Bulgaria | Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) | M | H |
M269 |
| BOY009 | 2901 BCE | Bulgaria | Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) | M | H13a1a1 |
Z2109 |
| BOY014 | 3316 BCE | Bulgaria | Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) | F | U5a1b |
|
| BOY019 | 2898 BCE | Bulgaria | Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) | M | U5a2b |
Z2109 |
| YUN033 | 3325 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | T2e2a |
|
| YUN034 | 2909 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | N1a1a1a |
|
| YUN035 | 3350 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | T2b |
|
| YUN036 | 2881 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | T2b |
|
| YUN037 | 3350 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | W1h |
CTS4002 |
| YUN038 | 2911 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | W1h |
CTS10936 |
| YUN039 | 2899 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | H11a |
|
| YUN041 | 2879 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | K1c1 |
|
| YUN042 | 2886 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | H |
|
| YUN043 | 2879 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | K1a3a |
|
| YUN044 | 3350 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | H1 |
|
| YUN045 | 2917 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | T2b |
|
| YUN048 | 4547 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | K1a1 |
P96 |
| YUN001 | 4533 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | K2a |
|
| YUN003_049 | 4600 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | U2+152 |
|
| YUN005 | 4450 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | U4a2 |
|
| YUN006_031 | 4486 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | K1a |
|
| YUN007 | 4447 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | H |
SK1359/Y7010/Z27851 |
| YUN009 | 4446 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | H62 |
FGC82036 |
| YUN012 | 4600 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | X2b |
|
| YUN013 | 4536 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | H7 |
Z38888 |
| YUN014 | 4456 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | T2b23 |
|
| YUN015 | 4446 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | HV+16311 |
L30/PF3267/S126 |
| YUN019 | 4600 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | U8b1a2b |
|
| YUN021 | 4342 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | K1a2 |
|
| YUN025 | 4600 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | X2b6 |
|
| YUN026 | 4539 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | M | T2e |
FGC8506 |
| YUN027_I0781 | 4600 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | K1a+195 |
|
| YUN028 | 4537 BCE | Bulgaria | Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) | F | H |
|
| VAR002 | 4608 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | X2 |
|
| VAR003 | 4750 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | H |
|
| VAR004 | 4684 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | J2b1 |
PF3148 |
| VAR006 | 4491 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | J1c |
L596/PF6907/S292 |
| VAR008 | 4703 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | T2b |
V88 |
| VAR009 | 4581 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | K1a1 |
L618 |
| VAR010 | 4688 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | U5b1 |
L131 |
| VAR011 | 4485 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | H |
PF3148 |
| VAR012 | 4673 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | T2b28 |
|
| VAR016 | 4541 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | T1a |
M70 |
| VAR017 | 4672 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | K1c |
|
| VAR018 | 4531 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | T2c1d1 |
L618 |
| VAR019 | 4700 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | H |
V88 |
| VAR020 | 4603 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | U5b1b1a |
V88 |
| VAR021 | 4547 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | K1a2 |
|
| VAR022 | 4586 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | H1e |
L446 |
| VAR023_ANI160 | 4684 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | H |
PF3359 |
| VAR026 | 4604 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | H |
V88 |
| VAR027 | 4674 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | K1 |
|
| VAR030 | 4545 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | K2a |
L701 |
| VAR032 | 4547 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | M | K1a19 |
L446 |
| VAR033 | 4713 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | U1a1d |
|
| VAR034 | 4681 BCE | Bulgaria | Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) | F | H87 |
|
| BOY001 | 2895 BCE | Bulgaria | Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) | M | R1a1a |
P297/PF6398 |
| PIE071631 | 3770 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | K1a2 |
M410/PF4941 |
| PIE039 | 5319 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | T2c1d1 |
|
| PIE041 | 4611 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | K1a+195 |
|
| PIE042 | 4539 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | T2 |
V88 |
| PIE043 | 4986 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | J1c15 |
|
| PIE044 | 4533 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | |
PF4610 |
| PIE048 | 4678 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H4a1 |
|
| PIE050 | 4581 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H11 |
Z38888 |
| PIE053 | 4492 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H11b |
|
| PIE054 | 4343 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | I5 |
P303/Page108/PF3340/S135/Z765 |
| PIE057 | 4486 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | HV+16311 |
Z38888 |
| PIE058 | 4341 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | I5 |
P303/Page108/PF3340/S135/Z765 |
| PIE06061 | 4776 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H+152 |
L701 |
| PIE061 | 4672 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H+152 |
L701 |
| PIE062 | 4346 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H |
P15/PF3112 |
| PIE063 | 4549 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | I5a |
Z38888 |
| PIE064 | 4589 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | K1a1b |
M269/PF6517 |
| PIE065 | 4676 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | K1a4 |
|
| PIE069 | 4588 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H |
|
| PIE003 | 4486 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | K1a24 |
|
| PIE004 | 4701 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H |
V88 |
| PIE005 | 4608 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | K1a+195 |
Z38888 |
| PIE006 | 4581 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | T2+16189 |
|
| PIE008 | 4489 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | T2b |
|
| PIE009 | 4604 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H |
A |
| PIE010 | 4441 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | K1a |
|
| PIE012 | 4648 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H7 |
|
| PIE013 | 4536 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H |
V88 |
| PIE014 | 4541 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H7 |
|
| PIE015 | 4612 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | V1a |
FGC12126 |
| PIE017 | 4708 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | J1 |
V88 |
| PIE018 | 4494 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | |
|
| PIE019 | 5000 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | T2b |
V88 |
| PIE022 | 4445 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | W3b |
PF3147 |
| PIE023 | 4603 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | J2b1 |
V88 |
| PIE025 | 4586 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H5 |
L206 |
| PIE026 | 4546 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | U3a1 |
L754/PF6269/YSC0000022 |
| PIE028 | 4494 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | K1a |
PF4610 |
| PIE029 | 4605 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | K1a+195 |
PF3359 |
| PIE030 | 4341 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | T2c1d1 |
|
| PIE032 | 4453 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | T2b |
P15/PF3112 |
| PIE033 | 4681 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | X2i+@225 |
FGC7739/Z6488 |
| PIE034 | 4681 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H5 |
|
| PIE035 | 4607 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | K1 |
|
| PIE037 | 4346 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | N1a1a1a3 |
P96 |
| PIE038 | 4676 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | K1a |
|
| PIE074 | 4360 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | T2c1d+152 |
|
| PIE075 | 4444 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | H |
|
| PIE076 | 4345 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | H2 |
Z38888 |
| PIE077 | 4339 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | F | T2b+152 |
|
| PIE078 | 3335 BCE | Romania | Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) | M | K1a1a |
L621/S392 |
| KTL001 | 3506 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | M | H2a1 |
I-S12195 |
| KTL002 | 3642 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | F | J1c5 |
|
| KTL003 | 3698 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | F | T2c1c1 |
|
| KTL004 | 3953 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | F | T2b |
|
| KTL005 | 3765 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | M | U3b3 |
R-M343 |
| KTL006 | 4157 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | M | U5a1a |
I-L699 |
| KTL007 | 3972 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | F | U4 |
|
| KTL008 | 3756 BCE | Ukraine | Kartal (Odessa Oblast) | F | U2e1b2 |
|
| MAJ002 | 4442 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | F | I1b*1 |
|
| MAJ003 | 3903 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | M | U5a1a1 |
G-P303 |
| MAJ004 | 2863 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | F | U5b2a1a1 |
|
| MAJ008 | 4232 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | F | I1a1 |
|
| MAJ009 | 4446 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | M | H5 |
R-L754 |
| MAJ017 | 2911 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | M | H2a3 |
R-Z2103 |
| MAJ019 | 2888 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | F | H1 |
|
| MAJ020 | 3949 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | F | U5a1f1 |
|
| MAJ023 | 4240 BCE | Ukraine | Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) | F | I5 |
|
| UBK003 | 3973 BCE | Ukraine | Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) | F | U5a1f1 |
|
| UBK006 | 3703 BCE | Ukraine | Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) | M | U4a2 |
I-P37.2 |
| USV004 | 3765 BCE | Ukraine | Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) | F | |
|
| USV005 | 3646 BCE | Ukraine | Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) | F | X2b |
|
Analysis
Comprehensive review of ancestry and genetic findings
Important Disclaimer: This review has been performed semi-automatically and is provided for informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, this analysis may contain errors, omissions, or misinterpretations of the original research. DNA Genics disclaims all liability for any inaccuracies, errors, or consequences arising from the use of this information. Users should independently verify all information and consult original research publications before making any decisions based on this content. This analysis is not intended as a substitute for professional scientific review or medical advice.