Menu
Research Publication

Early contact between late farming and pastoralist societies in southeastern Europe

Penske S, Rohrlach AB, Childebayeva A et al.

37468624 PubMed ID
29 Authors
2023 Aug Published
133 Samples
Scroll to explore
Chapter I

Publication Details

Comprehensive information about this research publication

Authors

PS
Penske S
RA
Rohrlach AB
CA
Childebayeva A
GG
Gnecchi-Ruscone G
SC
Schmid C
SM
Spyrou MA
NG
Neumann GU
AN
Atanassova N
BK
Beutler K
BK
Boyadzhiev K
BY
Boyadzhiev Y
BI
Bruyako I
CA
Chohadzhiev A
GB
Govedarica B
KM
Karaucak M
KR
Krauss R
LM
Leppek M
MI
Manzura I
PK
Privat K
RS
Ross S
SV
Slavchev V
SA
Sobotkova A
TM
Toderaş M
VT
Valchev T
RH
Ringbauer H
SP
Stockhammer PW
HS
Hansen S
KJ
Krause J
HW
Haak W
Chapter II

Abstract

Summary of the research findings

Archaeogenetic studies have described two main genetic turnover events in prehistoric western Eurasia: one associated with the spread of farming and a sedentary lifestyle starting around 7000-6000 BC (refs. 1-3) and a second with the expansion of pastoralist groups from the Eurasian steppes starting around 3300 BC (refs. 4,5). The period between these events saw new economies emerging on the basis of key innovations, including metallurgy, wheel and wagon and horse domestication6-9. However, what happened between the demise of the Copper Age settlements around 4250 BC and the expansion of pastoralists remains poorly understood. To address this question, we analysed genome-wide data from 135 ancient individuals from the contact zone between southeastern Europe and the northwestern Black Sea region spanning this critical time period. While we observe genetic continuity between Neolithic and Copper Age groups from major sites in the same region, from around 4500 BC on, groups from the northwestern Black Sea region carried varying amounts of mixed ancestries derived from Copper Age groups and those from the forest/steppe zones, indicating genetic and cultural contact over a period of around 1,000 years earlier than anticipated. We propose that the transfer of critical innovations between farmers and transitional foragers/herders from different ecogeographic zones during this early contact was integral to the formation, rise and expansion of pastoralist groups around 3300 BC.

Chapter III

Ancient DNA Samples

133 ancient DNA samples referenced in this publication

133 Samples
Sample ID Date/Era Country Locality Sex mtDNA Y-DNA
PTK001 4656 BCE Bulgaria Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) M HV+16311 M436/P214/PF3856/S33
PTK003 4674 BCE Bulgaria Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) M H3aq V88
PTK004 4656 BCE Bulgaria Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) M H3aq M436/P214/PF3856/S33
PTK005 4700 BCE Bulgaria Petko Karavelovo (Veliko Tarnovo province, Polski Tyrambesh municipality) M U2+152 CTS5990/Z1903
BOY008 2899 BCE Bulgaria Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) M H M269
BOY009 2901 BCE Bulgaria Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) M H13a1a1 Z2109
BOY014 3316 BCE Bulgaria Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) F U5a1b
BOY019 2898 BCE Bulgaria Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) M U5a2b Z2109
YUN033 3325 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F T2e2a
YUN034 2909 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F N1a1a1a
YUN035 3350 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F T2b
YUN036 2881 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F T2b
YUN037 3350 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M W1h CTS4002
YUN038 2911 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M W1h CTS10936
YUN039 2899 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F H11a
YUN041 2879 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F K1c1
YUN042 2886 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F H
YUN043 2879 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F K1a3a
YUN044 3350 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F H1
YUN045 2917 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F T2b
YUN048 4547 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M K1a1 P96
YUN001 4533 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F K2a
YUN003_049 4600 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F U2+152
YUN005 4450 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F U4a2
YUN006_031 4486 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F K1a
YUN007 4447 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M H SK1359/Y7010/Z27851
YUN009 4446 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M H62 FGC82036
YUN012 4600 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F X2b
YUN013 4536 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M H7 Z38888
YUN014 4456 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F T2b23
YUN015 4446 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M HV+16311 L30/PF3267/S126
YUN019 4600 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F U8b1a2b
YUN021 4342 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F K1a2
YUN025 4600 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F X2b6
YUN026 4539 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) M T2e FGC8506
YUN027_I0781 4600 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F K1a+195
YUN028 4537 BCE Bulgaria Yunatsite (Pazardzhik province) F H
VAR002 4608 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F X2
VAR003 4750 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F H
VAR004 4684 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M J2b1 PF3148
VAR006 4491 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M J1c L596/PF6907/S292
VAR008 4703 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M T2b V88
VAR009 4581 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M K1a1 L618
VAR010 4688 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M U5b1 L131
VAR011 4485 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M H PF3148
VAR012 4673 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F T2b28
VAR016 4541 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M T1a M70
VAR017 4672 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F K1c
VAR018 4531 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M T2c1d1 L618
VAR019 4700 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M H V88
VAR020 4603 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M U5b1b1a V88
VAR021 4547 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F K1a2
VAR022 4586 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M H1e L446
VAR023_ANI160 4684 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M H PF3359
VAR026 4604 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M H V88
VAR027 4674 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F K1
VAR030 4545 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M K2a L701
VAR032 4547 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) M K1a19 L446
VAR033 4713 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F U1a1d
VAR034 4681 BCE Bulgaria Varna (province Varna, municipality Varna) F H87
BOY001 2895 BCE Bulgaria Boyanovo (Yambol province, Elhovo municipality) M R1a1a P297/PF6398
PIE071631 3770 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M K1a2 M410/PF4941
PIE039 5319 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F T2c1d1
PIE041 4611 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F K1a+195
PIE042 4539 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M T2 V88
PIE043 4986 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F J1c15
PIE044 4533 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M PF4610
PIE048 4678 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H4a1
PIE050 4581 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H11 Z38888
PIE053 4492 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H11b
PIE054 4343 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M I5 P303/Page108/PF3340/S135/Z765
PIE057 4486 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M HV+16311 Z38888
PIE058 4341 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M I5 P303/Page108/PF3340/S135/Z765
PIE06061 4776 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H+152 L701
PIE061 4672 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H+152 L701
PIE062 4346 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H P15/PF3112
PIE063 4549 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M I5a Z38888
PIE064 4589 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M K1a1b M269/PF6517
PIE065 4676 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F K1a4
PIE069 4588 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H
PIE003 4486 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F K1a24
PIE004 4701 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H V88
PIE005 4608 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M K1a+195 Z38888
PIE006 4581 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F T2+16189
PIE008 4489 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F T2b
PIE009 4604 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H A
PIE010 4441 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F K1a
PIE012 4648 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H7
PIE013 4536 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H V88
PIE014 4541 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H7
PIE015 4612 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M V1a FGC12126
PIE017 4708 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M J1 V88
PIE018 4494 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F
PIE019 5000 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M T2b V88
PIE022 4445 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M W3b PF3147
PIE023 4603 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M J2b1 V88
PIE025 4586 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H5 L206
PIE026 4546 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M U3a1 L754/PF6269/YSC0000022
PIE028 4494 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M K1a PF4610
PIE029 4605 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M K1a+195 PF3359
PIE030 4341 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F T2c1d1
PIE032 4453 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M T2b P15/PF3112
PIE033 4681 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M X2i+@225 FGC7739/Z6488
PIE034 4681 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H5
PIE035 4607 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F K1
PIE037 4346 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M N1a1a1a3 P96
PIE038 4676 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F K1a
PIE074 4360 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F T2c1d+152
PIE075 4444 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F H
PIE076 4345 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M H2 Z38888
PIE077 4339 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) F T2b+152
PIE078 3335 BCE Romania Pietrele Măgura Gorgana (Giurgiu County) M K1a1a L621/S392
KTL001 3506 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) M H2a1 I-S12195
KTL002 3642 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) F J1c5
KTL003 3698 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) F T2c1c1
KTL004 3953 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) F T2b
KTL005 3765 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) M U3b3 R-M343
KTL006 4157 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) M U5a1a I-L699
KTL007 3972 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) F U4
KTL008 3756 BCE Ukraine Kartal (Odessa Oblast) F U2e1b2
MAJ002 4442 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) F I1b*1
MAJ003 3903 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) M U5a1a1 G-P303
MAJ004 2863 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) F U5b2a1a1
MAJ008 4232 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) F I1a1
MAJ009 4446 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) M H5 R-L754
MAJ017 2911 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) M H2a3 R-Z2103
MAJ019 2888 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) F H1
MAJ020 3949 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) F U5a1f1
MAJ023 4240 BCE Ukraine Majaky (Odessa Oblast, Odesa District) F I5
UBK003 3973 BCE Ukraine Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) F U5a1f1
UBK006 3703 BCE Ukraine Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) M U4a2 I-P37.2
USV004 3765 BCE Ukraine Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) F
USV005 3646 BCE Ukraine Usatove-Bolšoj Kujalnik (Odessa Oblast) F X2b
Chapter IV

Analysis

Comprehensive review of ancestry and genetic findings

Important Disclaimer: This review has been performed semi-automatically and is provided for informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, this analysis may contain errors, omissions, or misinterpretations of the original research. DNA Genics disclaims all liability for any inaccuracies, errors, or consequences arising from the use of this information. Users should independently verify all information and consult original research publications before making any decisions based on this content. This analysis is not intended as a substitute for professional scientific review or medical advice.

Summary

Key Findings

Ancestry Insights

Traits Analysis

Historical Context

Scientific Assessment