Social stratification without genetic differentiation at the site of Kulubnarti in Christian Period Nubia
Sirak KA, Fernandes DM, Lipson M et al.
Publication Details
Comprehensive information about this research publication
Abstract
Summary of the research findings
Relatively little is known about Nubia's genetic landscape prior to the influence of the Islamic migrations that began in the late 1st millennium CE. Here, we increase the number of ancient individuals with genome-level data from the Nile Valley from three to 69, reporting data for 66 individuals from two cemeteries at the Christian Period (~650-1000 CE) site of Kulubnarti, where multiple lines of evidence suggest social stratification. The Kulubnarti Nubians had ~43% Nilotic-related ancestry (individual variation between ~36-54%) with the remaining ancestry consistent with being introduced through Egypt and ultimately deriving from an ancestry pool like that found in the Bronze and Iron Age Levant. The Kulubnarti gene pool - shaped over a millennium - harbors disproportionately female-associated West Eurasian-related ancestry. Genetic similarity among individuals from the two cemeteries supports a hypothesis of social division without genetic distinction. Seven pairs of inter-cemetery relatives suggest fluidity between cemetery groups. Present-day Nubians are not directly descended from the Kulubnarti Nubians, attesting to additional genetic input since the Christian Period.
Ancient DNA Samples
66 ancient DNA samples referenced in this publication
| Sample ID | Date/Era | Country | Locality | Sex | mtDNA | Y-DNA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I19014 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | H2a |
|
| I19015 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | U5b2b5 |
|
| I19132 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | H2a |
|
| I19134 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | L0a1a1 |
|
| I19135 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | R0a1a |
|
| I19136 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | L5a1b |
|
| I19138 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | L3b1a2 |
|
| I19139 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | L0a1a1 |
|
| I19140 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | L5a1b |
|
| I19143 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I19144 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | H2a |
|
| I19145 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I19148 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | U3b2 |
|
| I6139 | 669 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | K1a19 |
|
| I6140 | 682 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | U5b2b5 |
|
| I6141 | 772 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | L2a1+143+16189 (16192) |
|
| I6250 | 706 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | H2a |
|
| I6251 | 774 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | L0a1a1 |
|
| I6252 | 702 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | H2a |
|
| I6253 | 772 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | H2a |
|
| I6327 | 893 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6328 | 773 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | J2a2e |
|
| I6330 | 673 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | U1a1 |
|
| I6340 | 772 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | U5b2b5 |
|
| I6138 | 669 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | H2a |
|
| I6331 | 784 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | M | H2a |
|
| I6329 | 772 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery R | F | N1b1a2 |
|
| I17449 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I17450 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | U5b2b5 |
|
| I17451 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | H2a |
|
| I17473 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | HV13a |
|
| I17477 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L5a1b |
|
| I17481 | 700 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | U5b2b5 |
|
| I17482 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L1b1a2a |
|
| I18507 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | U5b2b5 |
|
| I18508 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | U5b2b5 |
|
| I18510 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | H2a |
|
| I18511 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L3f1a1 |
|
| I18514 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | H2a |
|
| I18517 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | N1b1a2 |
|
| I18518 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L1b1a2 |
|
| I18519 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | J2a2e |
|
| I18520 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I18521 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | N1b1a2 |
|
| I18522 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I18525 | 700 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | U5b2b5 |
|
| I18536 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | N1a1a3 |
|
| I18538 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I18610 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | U5b2b5 |
|
| I6254 | 892 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L0a1a1 |
|
| I6255 | 706 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L0a1a1 |
|
| I6256 | 773 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6257 | 710 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6258 | 682 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | H2a |
|
| I6324 | 710 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6325 | 669 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6326 | 676 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6332 | 772 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I6333 | 682 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | T1a7 |
|
| I6334 | 772 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L1b1a2a |
|
| I6336 | 773 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | U5b2b5 |
|
| I6337 | 655 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | |
|
| I6338 | 656 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | H2a |
|
| I17475 | 750 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | L2a1d1 |
|
| I18612 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | M | H2a |
|
| I18509 | 650 CE | Sudan | Nubia. Kulubnarti. Cemetery S | F | L2a1d1 |
|
Analysis
Comprehensive review of ancestry and genetic findings
Important Disclaimer: This review has been performed semi-automatically and is provided for informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, this analysis may contain errors, omissions, or misinterpretations of the original research. DNA Genics disclaims all liability for any inaccuracies, errors, or consequences arising from the use of this information. Users should independently verify all information and consult original research publications before making any decisions based on this content. This analysis is not intended as a substitute for professional scientific review or medical advice.